Dear New York guy

We were like online friends who barely interacted for years. Then, I saw you were in my city and I invited you to my friend's birthday. That might've been a little crazy of me, and my friends told me that, but it didn't feel like I was inviting a stranger since I had "known" you for so long. That night, you gained so many fans- they still remember you. Everyone thought you were so outgoing and nice, even my man-hating friend really liked you. It's still funny to me how multiple people told you how attractive you were, yet you were so humble about it. I hope you're doing well.